Affiliates Marketers and Our Negative Stigma
For a while now, I've noticed a negative stigma that people have about affiliate marketing in general. It wasn't until I read about Jason Calacanis's controversial remarks in his keynote speech at ASW 08 regarding the business that it really struck a cord.
Among all things, stated, here are a few:
"Affiliates are polluting our own well - we should realize that."
"Affiliates need to realize they are at the bottom of the food chain and then work up from there."
"Affiliate marketers' big problem is that they are focused on short-term gains and think too small."
OK, I'll be real. For some affiliate marketers, this blanketed statement holds true. But for those of us who are thinking on a grander scale -- applying the model to traditional businesses and helping them to reach higher levels -- this is a slap in the face.
People like Calacanis consider what we do (not just some of us, all of us) spamming. He even goes so far as to say that people like Shoemoney who hold up their six-figure checks are pathetic for doing so when they could be holding up seven or eight-figure checks if they actually created something.
But haven't we created something? Would there be a supply if there were no demand? And are we spamming if people are coming to us to get what they want?
Aside from all those reasons, let's not ignore the obvious parallel to pyramid schemes. You remember, the schemes where you'd form a down-line who would always send money to you but you'd never move up in the chain. What we do is pretty different, yet we're grouped together with these crazy notions.
The fact is, we create sales where there would otherwise be none and we do so (most of us) through legitimate channels. We use referral programs as incentives to get other people to join the networks we use but it is in no way the primary business (unless you prefer that way).
As with anything else people don't understand, they fear it. Affiliate marketing doesn't sit outside that circle because what it actually is isn't immediately apparent to people. They don't realize it's just a different name for what people do already - referral marketing. Our biggest and most famous example? Amazon.com. That's where it all started, baby.
And to those who say it's like gambling: what business isn't? Over half of businesses fail within their first five years. Is there ever any guarantee you'll have customers to begin with? Or how about a year from the time your business starts? Whether it's online or brick-and-mortar, you depend on the chance that you'll have customers much like we depend on the chance that people will be searching for something in particular. Same idea, different medium.
Hopefully that clears up any crazy ideas people have about the business.








March 5th, 2008 at 1:18 am
I think the guy is just angry because now people can literally become millionaires overnight so to speak. I dunno how old the guy is but sounds like hes the one we all should be looking up to or something.
And i guarantee that the top affiliate marketers make a hell of a lot more than websites that have been around for years.
The only kind of 8-9 figure sites i know of are the top 500 in all the internet. Does the guy even know what hes talking about? He acts as if Creating a website and making it a 9 figure earning business is easy. Hell sites that make over 10,000 a month are considered very successful yet some affiliate marketers pull that in a couple hours.
sounds like an internet old timer. Although i do agree that this business isn’t a long term thing. But im sure everyone whos in it right now isn’t planning on making that much money forever. I know the first thing i would buy if i made a good chunk of money…
A website.
Probably one of the best investments you could ever make, If its solid and constantly growing niche then your pretty much guaranteed money as long as the net exists and its only growing more popular every day. The internet and computers are the next television the opportunities are huge and fresh get in while you can.
March 5th, 2008 at 3:47 am
There is a lot of negativity but the industry is pretty young still. People are just not aware of what it entails. They only see certain things, lone people working from home, terrible landing pages such as long sales pages, and often selling slightly controversial products such as ringtones. We all know you can download any song for free and stick it on your phone. Yet ringtones for huge premiums is huge business.
As internet marketing becomes more mainstream things will clear up.
March 5th, 2008 at 5:15 am
What I think makes us look bad is when affiliates promote shady offers like ringtones. We are pretty much influencing some 14 year old kid to put their phone number in and then get grounded when there parents get the bill. On top of this lots of the best paying offers are the “shady” offers so it puts us in a bad spot. I even promoted one of these offers as my first campaign. It charges 2.95 for shipping then 45 bucks a month. Only problem is that 45 was in super small print.
March 5th, 2008 at 5:16 am
ps: I put the wrong website if you do not mind changing it for me
March 5th, 2008 at 9:55 am
@will: Exactly. He makes a false comparison between an individual and an entire company. Even if it were a small group of guys, it’s still not comparable to a large company who does multiple millions/billions of dollars.
March 5th, 2008 at 10:05 am
@Tom: I agree with you mostly, but how long will that take? According to Wikipedia, affiliate marketing in general started in between 1994 and 1996. Fourteen years later, here we are and still there are people up in arms. It’s going to be a while.
March 5th, 2008 at 10:09 am
@Neil: I don’t think the intention of most sites is to dupe anyone into doing anything illegal or that they wouldn’t otherwise want to. Sure, we use a funnel to get people to the offer page but once they’re there, it’s up to them to complete the sale.
I mean, are offers any more shady than the fine print at the bottom of any contact with, say, a cell phone company or any more gimmicky than perhaps, search software that is written by humans? I say nay.
March 5th, 2008 at 10:39 am
Well, I find people approaching me here selling insurance products (not through the internet). They get commissions from the companies for marketing their products. Thats the same thing we are doing … “Marketing” other’s products using the Internet, generating sales for them using whatever method possible. Getting them customers for a fees.
Jason is too jealous …… Who invited him to give such a lecture affiliate summit when he doesnt really understand what affiliates are. They are marketers which were there 100 years back and will be forever.
March 5th, 2008 at 2:23 pm
Who’s Jason Calcanis? As if anyone really gives a shit what he thinks. Most likely after the keynote everyone went home and continued their “spammy” ways. If he wrote the checks I would be more inclined to maybe throw a glance his way. For now, I simply read around the web and realize while he did sell a multi million dollar company, why would you invite him to speak at an affiliate seminar if he wasn’t an expert in the field? A little misleading I think.
Anyway how’s life? You rock, keep it real,
Ruck
March 5th, 2008 at 3:21 pm
Aditya and Ruck both make a good point. I’m not really sure who invited him or why but one thing is for certain, he’s stirring things up and giving himself a lot of press. In fact, check this out:
http://google.com/trends?q=calacanis&date=2008
March 6th, 2008 at 10:26 am
Guy is notorious for being a loud-mouth, go-against-the-grain type of guy. Months ago when I heard he was going to be at ASW, “oh boy” came to mind.
Seemed like a way to get some buzz going around his search engine. The guy could have easily went to the SMX conference that was around the same time in Cali, but he opted for ASW - weird choice. Most likely because he would have been irrelevant there.
March 6th, 2008 at 10:30 am
@jayson: Hah, yeah. Seems like a publicity stunt if I ever saw one.