Yeah, I’ve noticed that there are several forums similar to what I’m suggesting already out there but I don’t like them. WickedFire is pretty cool but still, it lacks the cohesiveness that you mentioned.

I also like the idea of posting new offers in the forum for both consumption and feedback. That would work out great, I think.

A couple of suggestions I have here is to start a forum concentrating only on the top or top two affiliate network that you are using instead of many affiliate networks (80/20 rule).

This forum can also be used to post latest offers that the new affiliates can try out. There should be another area that can only be viewed by the members where they can post their landing page for your review (or other successful affiliates).

One thing I find lacking in other forums is the cohesiveness of the community (how open they are to share and participate). Therefore, one way to be unique is to group different affiliates (in terms of niche) and have them complete against other groups for prizes or simply a free review from you – this will enable the group members to help out each other and gain popularity. – just my thoughts =)